Click below to hear what to do if you grade everything:
“I grade everything because I feel like I have to—and because of it, I have no life.”
Sound familiar? If so, this final episode in our True Life Teacher Confession series is going to hit home. I’m digging into one of the most exhausting habits teachers fall into—and why it’s not the badge of honor we’ve been led to believe. If grading has taken over your evenings, weekends, and sanity, this is the pep talk (and reality check) you didn’t know you needed.
I’m breaking down what really happens when we try to grade it all, and why it’s costing us more than we think. You’ll hear the mindset shifts I believe every teacher needs before making any practical changes, plus why your students may be more capable of working without grades than you realize. If you’re ready to stop enabling apathy and start reclaiming your time, this episode is your starting point.
I’m also sharing how I’ve built a classroom culture where students do the work—even when it’s not graded—and why going cold turkey might be the reset you need. You don’t have to spend another year buried in papers. Let’s talk about what it really looks like to grade less, give better feedback, and actually have a life outside of school!
Topics Discussed
- The common teacher struggle of grading everything and feeling burnt out
- Negative effects of grading ALL student work
- Misconception that students need every assignment graded for motivation
- Importance of setting boundaries and changing grading habits decisively
- The two purposes that grading should serve and how to ensure that these purposes are fulfilled
- Practical tips for sustainable grading practices and creating an accountable classroom culture
Resources Mentioned:
- Culture Mini-Course
- Secondary Science Simplified Bundle
- Download your FREE Classroom Reset Challenge.
- Take the Free Labs When Limited virtual PD course
- Send me a DM on Instagram: @its.not.rocket.science
- Send me an email: rebecca@itsnotrocketscienceclassroom.com
- Follow, rate, and review on Apple Podcasts.
Related Episodes and Blog Posts:
- Episode 64, How to Re-Engage Apathetic Students (And Manage Your Own Apathy!)
- Episode 123, What to Do When You Care More Than Your Students Do
- Episode 145, How to Build Resilience in Students Post-Pandemic
- Episode 155, How to Create Active and Accountable Learners in Your Secondary Science Classroom
- Episode 160, 4 Proven Tips to INSTANTLY Decrease Your Grading Time
- Episode 187, True Life: I’m Drowning
Connect with Rebecca:
- Join the list
- Take the Free Labs When Limited virtual PD course
- Follow me on Instagram
- Like us on Facebook
- Shop my TpT Store
More about Secondary Science Simplified:
Secondary Science Simplified is a podcast specifically for high school science teachers that will help you to engage your students AND simplify your life as a secondary science educator. Each week Rebecca, from It’s Not Rocket Science, and her guests will share practical and easy-to-implement strategies for decreasing your workload so that you can stop working overtime and start focusing your energy doing what you love – actually teaching!
Teaching doesn’t have to be rocket science, and you’ll learn exactly what you need to do to simplify your secondary science teaching life so that you can enjoy your life outside of school even more. Head here to grab your FREE Classroom Reset Challenge.
Rebecca Joyner [00:00:01]:
It’s the final week in our True Life Teacher Confession series, and this week we’re ending with a really good one that I think a lot of you can relate to. This teacher said, I grade everything because I feel like I have to. I have no life because of it and no desire to want to grade. I need students to know that every assignment is important, even if it isn’t graded. So I just grade it all to motivate them. Does this sound familiar to you? I’m sure it does for so many of you, because I’ve been in this exact same place, and I have a lot to say about this because I am obsessed with supporting teachers and grading less in their classrooms. Because I really think when you look at all the responsibilities we have as secondary science teachers, grading becomes the one that is the easiest to cut back on and still have such an effective classroom culture, learning experience, all of that. So I desperately want to help this teacher who submitted this confession and anyone else who feels this way.
Rebecca Joyner [00:01:06]:
So let’s get right into it. This is Secondary Science Simplified, a podcast for secondary science teachers who want to engage their students and simplify their lives. I’m Rebecca Joyner from It’s Not Rocket Science. As a high school science teacher turned curriculum writer, I am passionate about helping other science teachers, love their job, serve their students, and do it all in only 40 hours a week. Are you ready to rock the time you spend in your classroom and actually have a life outside of it? You are in the right place, teacher friend. Let’s get to today’s episode. So this teacher’s confession had a lot in it, so I’m gonna break it apart into two chunks, and I just kind of want to bust some misconceptions that I heard when reading this confession, and then I’ll hit you with some solutions at the end for how we’re going to combat this. So first, this teacher said, I want to remind you, I grade everything because I feel like I have to.
Rebecca Joyner [00:02:06]:
I have no life because of it and no desire to want to grade. And when I hear that, I think, of course you have no life. Like, if you grade everything, you will literally have no life. Unless you’re, like, a speed grader. Or maybe if you have, like, a double planning period and only one prep and no extracurricular responsibilities, like, if that’s you, then maybe you can grade every single thing. But if that doesn’t apply to you, then, yeah, you’re gonna have no life. Because here’s the problem that is always inevitable if you grade everything or nearly everything. It’s that you always get to the point that you have no desire to grade because it’s just too much.
Rebecca Joyner [00:02:46]:
And then when you have no desire to grade, it leads to one of three things happening. Typically, one, you rush through just to get it done. And then that means you’re going to have bad and not helpful feedback for them to learn from. You’re just going to get through it and scribble a number and they’re not going to be able to really learn from what they did wrong. Two, it can mean that you give delayed feedback and then, then your students are receiving it so much later than after they did it, and then they don’t even remember doing it. You’re turning back a lab a week or two after they did it. They don’t even remember what that lab was about. And I also find that if you do delayed feedback, you tend to grade unfairly because you’re doing it in chunks.
Rebecca Joyner [00:03:29]:
Like you’re grading a few people’s here, a few people’s there. And, and when you do that, you’re not really giving partial credit as consistently. That’s what I found in my experience. And then third, when you have no desire to grade, you literally end up spending all your time outside of contract hours grading. Maybe you’re doing that so you can give them quality feedback and timely feedback, but then you burn out in three to five years because of your job and it has become your life instead of just being your job like we talked about in a past episode. So again, when you’re grading all these things, one of three things is going to inevitably happen. You’re going to be rushing and not giving good feedback. You’re going to be giving good feedback, but it’s delayed.
Rebecca Joyner [00:04:08]:
And then that’s not really as helpful for your students. And typically when you do the delayed grading, it’s not as fair. Or three, you’re going to give quality feedback and timely feedback, but then you’re having no life and then you’re going to burn out. Okay, so that’s a lot of issues there. Now let’s talk about the other thing that this teacher said. They said, I need students to know that every assignment is important, even if it isn’t graded. So I just grade it all to motivate them. Okay? And I’m not trying to be dramatic here, but if you feel this way, just like this teacher, to me that means your students have gaslit you.
Rebecca Joyner [00:04:42]:
They have convinced you that they have no, they have no intrinsic motivation whatsoever and can only be motivated to do anything if they have a reward to it. And I’m not saying that’s. Maybe it’s not entirely gaslighting, maybe there is truth to it and maybe they really do feel that way. But that is some unhinged apathy that is crazy town to hear coming out of the mouths of 14 to 18 year olds, which is the ages of most of your students, okay? They are way too old to have that much immaturity and that little resilience, okay? And I’m not saying this is your fault per se, okay? This is a chronic problem we’ve all seen over the last five years since the pandemic, and it’s just being reinforced over and over again until we start to put our foot down and really push students to be different, okay? And I have so many thoughts about this. I have four podcast episodes you need to listen to that I’ve already recorded in the past that address this kind of ideology that your students might be having in this kind of attitude they might be having and lack of work ethic. So I have episode 64, how to re engage apathetic students and maybe manage your own apathy. If that’s a problem for you. Episode 155 is how to create active and accountable learners in your classroom.
Rebecca Joyner [00:06:11]:
Episode 145 is how to build resilience in students post pandemic. And then episode 123 is what to do when you care more than your students because it sounds like you care about their grades more than they do, since you’re grading everything for them to make them do stuff. So episode 64, 155, 145, 123, all touch on things that I think would really help you with this. But to summarize before you just leave this episode and go some of those is the only way we can combat this is by actively pushing against it and holding the line. And this is the perfect time to talk about this with you in the school year because you can set a different precedent next school year. Just stop doing it, y’ all. I’m not a parenting expert by any means. I only have my sample size is three children.
Rebecca Joyner [00:07:05]:
But I have noticed over and over again as I’ve parented my children through different stages that quitting cold turkey tends to be the best case scenario. I know, like people talk about what they do when there’s a time change with their kids, sleeping schedule, or when they have to get rid of the paci, or when they drop the swaddle. I know these are A lot of baby things or, you know, when they decide to transition to the big boy bed or get rid of diapers or whatever. Like, I genuinely think in all these different things that I’ve done, just cutting it cold turkey and saying, okay, we’re not doing that anymore. This is the new thing has gone so much better than trying to do something gradual. You know, for instance, okay, it’s time change. Okay, now we get up an hour later. We get up an hour earlier.
Rebecca Joyner [00:07:46]:
I’m not doing this, like, 15 minutes every day. We just change the alarm. That’s what we do. I remember every time I potty trained with my children, one day they woke up and there were no more diapers in the house. And it’s like, here’s the potty. And this is where we go. I genuinely think it’s very painful, but it’s very painful for a short amount of time. And when you hold the line on these things, they just learn to fall in line.
Rebecca Joyner [00:08:09]:
Whereas when you try to do things really gradually, I think back to the dropping the swaddle days, and a lot of friends are like, okay, I’m gonna do one arm out, and then I’m gonna do, you know, two arms out, but they’re in a sleep sack, and da, da. And it, like, ends up taking, you know, three to six months. I just think changing things sharply and drastically is a great way to do it. And this clean cut of a new school year and starting fresh and new students is a great way to do it. Y’ all, every teacher I interview on this podcast, who I ask about grading, this is not. This is real life. If you go back to every guest interview, they all say that they just don’t grade everything and they have a culture where their students do the work anyway. And you can create that culture, too.
Rebecca Joyner [00:08:54]:
It just. You cannot start with the habit of, like, I’ll grade everything, and now I’m going to slowly grade less and less and less. They’re just going to complain and moan and groan. You just have to say, I’m not doing this. I have a course on how to create a classroom culture that’s a part of the Secondary Science Simplified Virtual PD bundle. I’ll link in the show notes. We talk about stuff like this, but you have to create a culture where you’re not enabling this kind of behavior. And I want you to know that you can put a stop to this.
Rebecca Joyner [00:09:20]:
Like, it doesn’t have to be this way. Okay? So I hope that you hear this with love, because, like, I want something different. For you. Like, I don’t want you to hear this as like, you’re doing a terrible job because you’re not. You’re not at all. You’re, I think again, teachers are naturally altruistic and you care so much about your students to the detriment of yourself. And I just want to get back into healthy, more healthy equilibrium, if you will. So you have to put a hard line in the sand.
Rebecca Joyner [00:09:49]:
Like, I’m not going to grade everything. This is what I will grade. And now let’s talk practically. Let’s talk solutions. Okay, how do we think about grading correctly so that then we’re grading in a way that serves them and also is sustainable for us? I think it starts with remembering that grading should serve two purposes and one of them is not getting your students motivated to do work. There’s two purposes to grading. One, informing you, the teacher of where your students are so that you can adjust your instruction accordingly. And then two, informing them of where they are so that they can get remedial help as they need it.
Rebecca Joyner [00:10:30]:
Now in order for these two purposes to be fulfilled, then everything you grade needs to one, actually be read by you because then you’re not going to actually be able to use it to inform your instruction or tell them how they’re doing. Two, be given quality and clear feedback. And three, everyone’s least favorite be graded and returned and gone over with students within 24 hours. I think this is so important. This lets them see the feedback while it’s fresh in their minds and have time to get help if they do see, oh, I need remedial help here. And then it allows you to adjust your lesson plans if you see that the majority of the class is struggling. So for example, when I teach heredity in my biology class and I’m teaching punnett squares, we do punnett squares in class for a few days and I do check things for a completion just for like a little 10 point. Like if you’re like, they will not be motivated, you could do a little ten point check.
Rebecca Joyner [00:11:34]:
Okay. To make them do stuff. I think that’s an easy compromise here. But usually about day three, I will then collect something that they’ve done about punnett squares. And actually I read every single thing. I grade it, I provide feedback, whatever, I get that back to them the next day. If I see that the majority of the class is like not getting it, we’re not moving on to dihybrids, we’re going to stay in mono hybrids a little longer. But if most people are getting it this just tells me, oh, these three to five students, they need to come in for tutoring and they have time to do that now before they get to the quiz on punnett squares, or especially before we get to my heredity unit test.
Rebecca Joyner [00:12:11]:
So it serves everyone this way when you treat grading this way. Now, how do we actually do this? Okay. How do we get to the place where everything we grade we actually have the time to read, give feedback to and return quickly? One, you stop using grading for motivation for your students. Again, see all those episodes I previously mentioned at the beginning of the year. If this feels like way too drastic, switch to doing some spot checks for completion. But not like a hundred point completion. That’s insane. Like 10 points because you did the practice handout.
Rebecca Joyner [00:12:43]:
Cool. I’ll check you off and give you the 10 out of 10 because you got through all of it. Whatever. Okay. But we’re not going to treat grading as motivation for students to do work. Grading is to inform you and is to inform them. The second thing is you train your students from day one to work without the reward of grading. One of the ways I do this is I do not tell them what’s graded and what’s not.
Rebecca Joyner [00:13:06]:
They should not need to know because knowing whether or not it’s graded should not be the motivating factor for how hard they try. Now, of course, will that give some of your students some anxious feelings? Yes. But if they see that you’re a generous grader and you’re still giving them plenty of grades, there’s still plenty of buffer grades in there with completion stuff. They learn to not stress out about this. Obviously, they know tests are going to be graded, but they don’t need to know every lab is going to be graded. Or especially when you do a lab, they don’t need to know which parts are going to grade. And you don’t need to know need to grade every part of every lab. And that comes to point three, you have to actively choose to grade way less.
Rebecca Joyner [00:13:41]:
And I have an entire podcast episode of tips about this talking about labs, specifically all sorts of things. Episode 160. I’ll link it in the show notes as well. You need to listen to that one too. Okay. But this is how we actually do this. So here is your take home challenge today. And I don’t normally do this, but here it is.
Rebecca Joyner [00:14:01]:
Okay, I want your help on this because sometimes I feel like when we’re on a hamster wheel of grading everything, it’s almost like a cult. And when you’re in A cult. Your reality gets distorted and we can’t remember what’s true and what’s not. And so it’s impossible to imagine life being a different way. So some of you are listening to me talking for the last 10 minutes and you’re like, rebecca, you’re crazy. And what you’re saying is impossible. And so here’s what I need. If you’re listening, if you have heard me talk about this stuff, whether that’s because you took my secondary science simplified course and it’s all over that course, or you’ve just heard me talking about this on the podcast for the last three plus years and you’ve implemented some of these changes I recommended, and you’ve kind of gotten out of this unhealthy, grading cult mindset, and you’ve seen what it’s like to have life on the other side.
Rebecca Joyner [00:14:54]:
Will you please, please DM me on Instagram and tell me it’s not rocket science? Rebecca Joyner. That’s my name. I’d love this week that this episode airs to just have a bunch of case studies from y’ all that are on the other side of this who maybe didn’t believe me when I said this was possible. And then you tried it and now you’ve seen the other side and I want to reshare them. It’ll be anonymous, of course. I always will, like, crop out your name and I put, like, a heart over your picture so no one can see. But I just think social proof would help. So many teachers listening to see that this is.
Rebecca Joyner [00:15:28]:
This is something that they can experience too. So if you’re willing to help me help others be pulled out of that, like, grating pit of doom, please DM me on Instagram. It would make me so happy. If you’re not an Instagram person, you can always email me Rebecca@it’sandrocketscienceclassroom.com I’d love to hear from you. That’s your take home challenge today. And if you’re like, I’m in the pit of doom and I don’t see how this is possible, follow me on Instagram so you can look out for those screenshots that hopefully I’ll be able to post and then also listen to, check out the show notes, which can be found at it’s not rocketscienceclassroom.com episode 189 and you’ll find links to all those old episodes. I’ve done that. Really talk about this so much because I just want you to hear them.
Rebecca Joyner [00:16:11]:
Because I just want life to be so different for you this school year, it sounds like probably I’ve had an energy drink, which I don’t, but, like, I just want to hug each of you so hard that’s listening to this and then maybe, like, grip your shoulders and shake you a little bit and be like, it can be different. And this is such a good time of year to decide to do things differently and have that fresh start at the beginning of the year. Fresh group of students. A different life is possible. You can have a life because teaching is not your life. It is your job. And we can stop grading everything. You can do it.
Rebecca Joyner [00:16:44]:
I promise you. Okay, shoot me that DM on Instagram. I would love to hear from you who have been on the other side. Let’s help each other out. All right, teacher friends, that wraps up today’s episode. If you’re looking for an easy way to start simplifying your life as a secondary science teacher, head to itsnotrocketscienceclassroom.com challenge to grab your classroom reset challenge. And guess what? It’s totally free. Thanks so much for tuning in, and I’ll see you here next week.
Rebecca Joyner [00:17:11]:
Until then, I’ll be rooting for you, teacher friend.