Click below to hear how to get students to care:
As educators, we decided to make this our career because we love to help people and care about students and their success. However, just because that’s our personality and mission, unfortunately, doesn’t mean that’s how our students feel. One of the resounding themes from the survey I sent out was how do I get my students to care as much as I do? I’ve heard this a lot, so I wanted to address it on the podcast. So, in today’s episode, I’m sharing why this seems to be the case and what you can practically do to move forward and keep serving your students.
It’s no secret that we seem to care more about our students’ success and learning of the content. Due to this, we need to always be reminded of the reality of our situation and how this impacts the disparity in how much our students care. But truly, what can we practically do? There are three things both you and your students need to implement and realize. While some might seem harsh, it’s what students need to realize or experience in order to change their outlook and work ethic in the future.
Our students not caring as much as we do is a tale as old as time, but the disparity seems to be greater in recent years. This has sparked concern from teachers and required a need to take action in order to best serve students. So, if you’re looking for ways to get your students to care as much as you do or change your perspective on it, this episode is for you!
Topics Discussed:
- Why students don’t care as much as you do has increased over the past few years
- 3 things you can practically do to help them care and keep serving your students
- Why natural consequences might be the best option to achieve this goal
- Ways to do your due diligence by getting others involved in order to get students to care
Resources Mentioned:
- Download your FREE Classroom Reset Challenge
- Send me a DM on Instagram: @its.not.rocket.science
- Send me an email: rebecca@itsnotrocketscienceclassroom.com
- Follow, rate, and review on Apple Podcasts
Related Episodes and Blog Posts:
- Episode 122, How to Nail Your Teacher Job Interview + 3 Mock Lesson Ideas
- Episode 121, Burned Out? When It’s Time to Make a Change
- Episode 120, How to Cut Your Grading Time in Half
- Episode 113, What to Do When You Have No Energy – Truths for the Classroom
- Episode 111, Priorities and Boundaries in the New Year
- Episode 57, Living and Working in Your Current Season
- Episode 56, Scheduling Rest – Why You Need To and How To Do It
- Episode 55, Goal Setting for the New Year – A Different Approach
Connect with Rebecca:
- Join the list
- Follow me on Instagram
- Like us on Facebook
- Join the Secondary Science Simplified Course Waitlist
- Shop my TpT Store
More about Secondary Science Simplified:
Secondary Science Simplified is a podcast specifically for high school science teachers that will help you to engage your students AND simplify your life as a secondary science educator. Each week Rebecca, from It’s Not Rocket Science, and her guests will share practical and easy-to-implement strategies for decreasing your workload so that you can stop working overtime and start focusing your energy doing what you love – actually teaching!
Teaching doesn’t have to be rocket science, and you’ll learn exactly what you need to do to simplify your secondary science teaching life so that you can enjoy your life outside of school even more. Head to itsnotrocketscienceclassroom.com/challenge to grab your FREE Classroom Reset Challenge.
Rebecca 0:00
I’m still poring over the hundreds of responses I got from you all in my annual survey for the secondary science amplify podcast. And the resounding theme of responses this year, said something along the lines of how do I get my students to care as much as I do, like I’ve seen it over and over and over again. And that’s why I’m doing this episode. Because the reality is that as much as we want our students to care, they simply don’t right now. And for most of us who care a lot, because we chose to do this job, that’s going to end up meaning that we care more than they do that just going to be a fact that even if it is, you know, just a plain reality, it’s also an exhausting reality, you know, trying to rally someone to care about their own learning and their grades, and their future and their general well being. It’s exhausting. And so in this episode, we’re going to talk about why this seems to always be the case of us caring more than our students. Why it’s even worse now than it ever used to be before kind of what your options are, and then how practically to move forward in a way that is going to keep serving your students. But that’s also sustainable for you, the teacher in order to stay in this profession long term. So let’s dive in. This is secondary science simplified a podcast for secondary science teachers who want to engage their students and simplify their lives. I’m Rebecca joiner from it’s not rocket science. As a high school science teacher turned curriculum writer, I am passionate about helping other science teachers, love their jobs, serve their students, and do it all in only 40 hours a week. Are you ready to rock the time he’s been in your classroom and actually have a life outside of it? You are in the right place teacher, friend, let’s get to today’s episode.
First and foremost, why does this happen? Why do we so often find that we care so much more than our students do about their success in our class and about learning? I think the better question is, why do we expect them to care as much as we do? I mean, honestly, you will care about this more than they do. Why do I know that? One? You chose this job? They did not choose to be in your class? Most likely, okay. Most likely, they are required to be in your class, legally, because they have to go to school. And you probably teach classes that are required to graduate high school, okay. And maybe you’re like, Well, I teach this elective course. And they didn’t have to sign up, well, maybe their parents sign them up. Maybe their advisor or their school counselor said, you need another class. And this one works in your schedule. And so you have to be here, okay, but I just think the majority of our students are not in our classrooms by choice. We are in our classrooms, by choice, even if it may feel like you’re kind of locked in there for this career forever. That’s not the case. I have past episodes about this. You can listen to to kind of assess, do you need to stay? Or do you need to go check out 121 and 122? Okay, but we’re on episode 123. Right now. So let’s stay the course here. But I think this is an important way to switch our mindset. Like, I think it’s so depressing, just to constantly think like, I care so much more than they do. Why don’t they care so much as me? And instead think, why do I expect him to care as much as I do, and letting go of that expectation that their care level will match yours? Because I think also not only did you choose to be here and they didn’t. But if you’re choosing to be in the education field, I’m venturing to guess that you by nature are a helper, you chose to be in a helping profession. Okay, there are other helping professions you could have chosen. You could have been in the medical field in any sort of capacity. That’s a helping profession, okay? There’s so many things, I’m not going to list them all, because you’re here now, and I’m telling you that teaching is a helping profession. So I know you care about helping these students. And some people, of course, naturally care more than others. I know we all get into this for different motivations. But I just don’t think you end up here unless you care about students and you care about them learning. So of course, you will care more. Okay. So that’s why we’re here. I also will say, I think the reason this is coming up in my survey results more so then in past years I’ve done surveys is because the disparity and care levels is so much greater now post pandemic. I think prior to the pandemic, teachers always cared more, but it wasn’t has obvious, whereas now the level of apathy, and honestly, I would say, apathy, but also atrophy, the atrophy of their learning muscles and of their caring muscles, and of their attention span muscles. There, it’s all so atrophied that it just feels like they care so much less than we do, okay, it’s just this huge disparity. But this, this carry more than our students, it’s the tail is oldest time, now, it just feels like the gap is so much greater. So that’s the depressing truth of it, what are our options? Let’s think about this, logically, you have two options, you can either care less, or you can get them to care more. Okay, that’s really all we have here. Now, we don’t have a lot of control over them. So it feels like the easiest option is to say you need to care less, rather than keep you spinning your wheels, trying and trying and trying to get them to care more. But at the same time, I don’t want you to just become this blob, who doesn’t care about students and like is just going through the motions, because that’s not a win for anyone, either. I just don’t want you to also, though, on the other extreme, have this pressure to be like I have to motivate them to care that is too much of a burden for you to bear. Now, I will say I do think your enthusiasm is contagious. I think it is our responsibility in any sort of leadership role, especially in an educational leadership role, to maintain a positive attitude as best we can. I really think especially in these apathetic times, we have to lead by example, here, students are so surrounded by negativity and negative voices all around them in the world, through their phones, through their headphones, you know, this is what they’re hearing, really staying positive, is key here. And I know this is very, very hard. But I think the best you can do to stay positive, that’s one way that you can show your care for them. And that could maybe inspire a little bit more care on their part in turn, because you’re staying positive. And you’re not just slamming this down their throats with negativity, like not just talking about all they stand to lose, but also focusing on what you stand to gain if you start to care about this more. So how do we move forward? And how do we get these students to move forward, especially this time of year, I know you probably have students that may not be passing your class, and you have seniors, that means they may not be graduating. So I realized that this is dire. Okay, but how to move forward, I’m going to give you some tips here, I’m really going to give you three things here that I want you to do. And these three things are going to hopefully, help you care less, but also help you get them to care more, because like I said at the top of this episode, we want to serve our students. Of course, that is number one priority. But like, the very closest second priority, if not tied for first is the sustainability for you as a teacher. And so you cannot be dragging these kids across the finish line. Okay, you should not be doing that. So here’s how we move forward. First, we put things in their proper place, we put things in their proper place. And this is a mental thing that you need to do. You need to know in your mind that this is your job. This is not your life. I’ve talked about this so many times on this podcast, you cannot use your students successes and failures. As the report card for how you are and who you are as a person, you really shouldn’t even use them to reflect who you are and how you are as a teacher, okay, because there are so many things going on in their lives that are so outside of your scope and sequence and capacity and capability of impacting your students successes and their failures cannot be the rubric in which you find any sort of personal value. Okay? Because this is your job, it’s not your entire life. Being a teacher does not define who you are as a whole human. And even still, this is your job. Okay? But your job has a ton of things that go into it besides just whether or not your students pass or fail. You know, they say you can lead a horse to water but you can’t make them drink that is a true statement. Okay, that is true. All that you can do is your absolute best within your current capacity in your current season of life, which is constantly varying, and then you have to shut the door on it and let it be, you are a human, you can only do so much. And at the end of the day, we are not responsible for their lives. Unless you are the legal parent or guardian of your students. You do not have this responsibility over them. Okay, so you need to give your yourself, Grace. Now, you do everything that you need to do on your end, which we’re going to talk about in a second. But then you need to let the consequences lie where they lie, okay? You cannot do the work, take the test or walk that graduation stage for them, they have to do it, we can set them up for success, but the end of the day, they have to do it. And I think especially I’m keep mentioning this, but I think students are extra, you know, bad at this right now, I was gonna say suck, like, they suck at this right now. Because their resiliency muscles and their go getter muscles, like I said, that getting or just atrophied. They, they just don’t have that energy within them anymore. It’s hard for them to muster that up. So I think you need to give yourself grace, like, you’re working with extremely hard test subjects here, okay, it’d be a lot easier to work in a lab, right now can be working with chemicals, or even micro organisms, those of you a lot easier test subjects, then 30 to 150 high school students. So I want you to put things in their proper place. And that is take all of the emotions you’re feeling about this. And the shame you may be feeling and the guilt, let’s put them in an appropriate box. And let’s file that away. And let’s separate that from your identity, who you are as a person and even who you are as a teacher. Because again, this is not fully define you, you will have students that fail, maybe every year of your entire career. Okay? It is not a measure of whether or not you’re a good teacher, your due diligence is and that’s what we need to do next to move forward. We put things in its proper place, and we do our due diligence. There should be no surprises at the end of the year ever. A student should never be surprised to find out that they’re failing or not passing or not getting an A plus plus extra star unicorn sticker. Their parents should never be surprised by this admin, school counselor, any of the major players, there should be no surprises. Because you’re doing your due diligence here all year long. It is your responsibility to make it clear to the students where they are. The Gradebook should be updated daily. Yes, I said daily grade books are now live. You know, they’ve been live since they’ve been digital, which is a lot of time, they should be daily updated. If you can’t keep up with that responsibility, then I think you need to be grading less things. And I’ve talked about this in a previous podcast episode that I’ll link in the show notes. But you should have dash should be a live document constantly up to date. It’s so so clear what grades are missing, what grades are graded. Like if you’re grading less stuff, you’ll be able to collect something graded that day, put it in the gradebook, give it back the next day, I feel really, really passionate about this. It’s it serves your students and it serves you. That’s why I don’t collect something unless I can grade it that quickly. Because I think that’s really important for them. So it needs to be so clear. We’re not waiting to the third quarter, we’re not waiting to fourth quarter, we’re not even really waiting for any quarter report card. You know, these are things that need to come out before the progress support, we’re going to be proactive about communication. I said this before, I used to shy away from talking to parents, I hated having those hard conversations. I always want to deal with things in house with my students. That is not best practice. We need to bring in all of the major players, especially at a time like this where students are so so so atrophied in terms of caring, and they just don’t care. We need to bring in other people to help them care. Okay, so we always are keeping it clear where they are. We’re always providing opportunities to catch up. Now, am I expecting you to bend over your back and Miss dinnertime with your family to tutor a kid who hasn’t turned in any assignments this year? Absolutely not. But you’re saying, Hey, I offer tutoring every afternoon from three to 330. Monday mornings before school, and Wednesdays at lunch. Those opportunities are available to you to catch up. I will be here all of those times. And I would love to help you catch up during those times. Maybe you can’t do any afternoons. Okay, but maybe your department can divvy up tutoring time. I had a school once where we had five biology teachers. So we each took an afternoon where we stayed an hour and a half late. And every one of us had a day you had Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, and we took anyone students, and it was such a blessing to the students. Some of them learned better from teachers that weren’t the one that they had. And so it was a way for us to serve each other and serve students and take one for the team. That’s an example of a PLC that’s really doing something practical to help each other and serve students divvying up tutoring days. Okay, so you’re giving them those opportunities. The other thing you’re doing is you’re being realistic about ketchup expectations. If we’re at this point in the year, three quarters in and someone has 75 zeros, there’s no way we’re gonna get quality work for 75 assignments. So am I saying that you ignore every single one of those? No. But I am also saying, maybe let’s be realistic about the expectations that we have for our students, if we want them to actually catch up, we make it clear, we make it clear to admin and parents like I’m doing them a solid, and lowering the expectations of what was originally expected. But we’re not just going to like hide that we’ve taken one for the team here, but we are going to be realistic, you know, I was talking to an older mom who I have a close relationship with who’s kind of like a step ahead of me parenting wise. So we go on walks, and she has a kid in middle school in high school. And you know, I got my first is just in kindergarten. So like, I’m still in the baby trenches. But one of her students or one, excuse me, one of her children, has some serious mental health problems, and it results in him being out of school. Very frequently, he has a lot of absences. You know, he has a fiver, forget his accommodations, but they’re just doing whatever they can, as a team, with the schools as a psychologist, the parents, whatever, whether it’s virtual classes, whatever it may be, how do we just get him through the best that he can do without further aggravating the issues that he has. And he has one specific teacher, that will not change the amount of grades that he is expected to bring in, that is still expecting him to do you know, 75 assignments, even though he’s only there 60% of the time of all the other students. And you may say, well, she’s right, and it’s unfair. But I also think we need to read situations and context and be realistic about our expectations for students. Because let’s be honest, is the goal for them to do all these assignments? Or is the goal for them to learn the content? The goal is for them to learn the content. So what’s the minimal amount of work we should be asking them to do to learn the content? That’s the way we should be approaching the ketchup expectations? How short? Can I make this ketchup list? Not how difficult can I make this kit for this kid to pass the class. And again, y’all know the situations, you can read the room and figure out who’s really just working the system, and who is truly having a hard time having a medical issue or having a mental health problem, and we needed to support them as best we can. Okay, the next thing we need to do in terms of doing our due diligence is get parents and other adults involved. You should never be dealing with these struggling students alone. And again, by yourself because you’re caring more than them. You should not be doing this by yourself. We’re talking to parents and guardians, we’re talking to the school counselor, the social worker, or potentially bringing in the school psychologist and resource teacher. If there’s potentially a learning disability happening here, that’s gone undiagnosed. Y’all. I had a girl one time, who is taking chemistry for the second time just trying to graduate high school. And they were like, can we just bring in someone else who’s not our teacher to tutor her in chemistry, and I tutored her two times, and I was the first person to come to her teacher, her actual chemistry teacher, her admin and her parents and say, I’m 90% sure she has dyslexia. They went on to not get her tested until she got to college and had such a hard time her freshman year of college, her freshman year of college, she finally got an official diagnosis for dyslexia, and realize, oh, this is why school has been so hard for me the last 16 years. This is why it’s been hard. Okay, so we cannot let these kids slip through the cracks if there’s something deeper going on here. And like I said, of course, getting the parents involved. So we’re going to make it clear where students are at all times, it’s never going to be surprised if they’re behind or not. We’re going to provide opportunities to catch up, we’re gonna be realistic about this ketchup expectations. We’re gonna get others involved. So we’re not caring and shouldering this burden on our own. We’re going to remind and reinforce the consequences. We remind them of what we are asking them to do. We reinforce the consequence of what will happen if they don’t do it, you will not pass this class, you will have to take summer school, you will have to do a continuing ed requirement. If it’s a senior, you will not walk, you will not get your high school diploma. Okay. And then
we take that deep breath, and we give them space to make their own choices. I’m speaking to the high school teachers here, especially, we are dealing with growing young adults. They leave our walls and they are officially legal individuals. They’re 18 year old adults, I can do all of these things. Yes, they are still children. That’s why we’re doing our due diligence and making it clear providing opportunities being realistic, getting others involved reminding reinforcing like we’re doing all that. But we’re also then giving them space, giving them the autonomy they already have, that they’re very aware of, in terms we see it and how they don’t care. And we’re letting them make their own choices. And then we’re going to document everything. Everything you’ve done, how you’ve updated your gradebook, daily, all the ways you’ve offered tutoring, how you’ve been, you know, you’ve maybe eliminated some of the assignments you wanted them to originally do, just to try to make it more reasonable. You’re tracking every time you’ve contacted a parent or another, you know, adult to be involved here. All the times you remind him of course, we’re documenting everything. And then we’re letting the natural consequences ensue. Either they step up, and they do the work, and they pass the test and they walk the graduation stage, or they do not and they experience failure. And that’s where we come to how do we move forward, we accept reality, okay, so we put things in their proper place, we do our due diligence. And then and only then if you’ve done that due diligence, you can rest assured that you have done what you needed to do. And at the end of the day, you can accept reality that some students will fail. Like I said, it doesn’t mean you are a failure, there are things out of your control and things out of their control. And all you can do is control what’s within your control, okay. You are called to equip them with your resources, and access other resources that you have at your school available to help them. But that’s all you’re not, you’re not called to literally carry them across that graduation stage. That’s not your responsibility. And I think sometimes we feel this pressure because we’re like, I’m their last chance. And that isn’t true, there’s always another chance. If they’re not seniors, they can always retake the course, or take continuing ed or do summer school or whatever program your district has, you know, set up for them. I will never forget y’all when I taught at a private school for the first time, I had a couple sections of eighth grade physical science. And I just had students that did not care. They are not exaggerating at all. They just never ever been challenged before my class. And they were failing all year long. These five students, and I was doing the due diligence, all I was trying to get them in for tutoring, I was telling their parents, even their parents didn’t care, because they didn’t believe that these kids would actually fail. I even had one student say to my face, there’s no way I’ll fail, because my dad will come in and make sure that I didn’t fail. And this is major private school student energy, as I’m sure you can tell. But we got to the end of the year. And again, I’m doing that due diligence, I’m documenting everything, whatever. And we sat down with admin. And he was like, okay, these five students fail. What’s the protocol, they this school, y’all had never had a middle schooler fail any course. And we had truly done the best that we could with them. And this was a learning opportunity. And this was a high school course they were taking an eighth grade. I don’t know if your schools if you’re in a K 12 school, if you ever do that. And even like I know, some middle schools do this where like students can take algebra one or English one or something that’s like a high school course in eighth grade. This is one of those situations. And at the time, though, we didn’t have a physical science course for high school because we just everyone had always passed in eighth grade. And so what was the consequence, the school had to make a new section of high school physical science. And those five students were the only pupils. And another teacher taught it so that they can learn from someone else. And you know what, those students took it seriously. And then students never failed another class in high school, because they learned that, oh, if I actually don’t do anything, I will actually fail this class and have to repeat it. There was an actual consequence. Even seniors, you may be saying, well, I teach seniors. If they don’t pass, they don’t graduate. Okay. Maybe they go on and they get their GED, or they do something else. Or maybe they’re going to summer school that summer after senior year is the first time in their life that they’re really humbled. And they see the reality of consequences for their actions, and it changes their life. My best friend is a former coworker of mine, we met, we work together. And she was a high school counselor when I was teaching high school science. And she said, I mean, I talked her about this, she was like, I have so many stories in my over a decade of working with students, where students, some students, she said, just truly need to experience failure in order to finally understand the weight of their choices. You know, almost hit rock bottom, so to speak, that sounds so dramatic, but like they just especially in today’s age, where they’re just used to being passed along. I don’t know about you, but have you ever logged into someone’s you know, a student in your school district or your school system, logged into their profile, gone back and seeing their grades in middle school? I had this one freshman biology student that was one of the most pathetic students I’ve ever had in my life. And I couldn’t get his mom to care. I couldn’t get him to care. I was like, how did he even pass middle school, I went back and looked at his middle school record. And I could see that every single quarter, he had failed every single class. And then at the end of the year, they overrode every grade, and given him 60, fives so that he could pass. But when I went in and looked at the quarter by quarter I saw, this is why he is the way he is, because his entire life, he’s realized that, like, I don’t actually have to pass any of these classes, because they’re gonna pass me along through the system. And at some point, there has to be a change in the system, that that’s not the case, and a learning of again, a natural consequence, you’re not just out there punishing kids. And if that’s what your mindset tells you, you’ve got to get rid of that, that that’s a lie, you’re not punishing kids, you’re set, you’re doing your best to set them up for success, and provide all these opportunities, and only can they, you know, rise to the occasion. There are natural consequences. Again, I tell my, you told her not to touch the stove, because it’s hot. If he touches the stove and gets burned, that’s a natural consequence of his choice. Okay, I didn’t stick his hand on the burner, you know, but if I’m, if I’m not right there next time, and he runs up really fast. He’s so fast and touches it and I’ve told him, that’s a natural conference consequence, he never touches that burner again, okay. And sometimes I think our students have to experience touching the burner. And so, you know, I’m going to be honest, I actually think it’s a disservice to them. If we’re doing it all for them, we’re conditioning them to never mature. And they’re never going to learn from their actions if we don’t let them learn from their actions. And so I really hope today, you don’t leave exasperated by this podcast, I hope you leave affirmed that this is super hard, and that you are not alone in caring way more than your students do. And that this is probably the reality for the rest of your life. And I hope you walk away with really practical ways to move forward from here of putting things in their proper place mentally, of doing your due diligence as an educator, and all those specifics we talked through and then accepting the reality that this is going to be hard. And this is something I’m going to face every year. But it is not something that can’t be overcome. And so I hope that this is helpful. And I have a couple other episodes on the podcast that are kind of like pep talk esque, you know, like this one. And so if you need more, you know, pep talk, big sister cheerleader energy to pep you up to get through the rest of the school year. Head to the shownotes you can find those. It’s not rocket science classroom.com/episode 123 Episode 123. Also, I will say if you haven’t left a review, you can be my cheerleader back and leave one. I would love that. But I would love it. If you would leave a review today. If you are a helper and you got into this profession to help people. I’m so glad you’re here. I’m so glad you’re helping students. And I hope you feel affirmed in what you’re doing. And serving students in a way that does serve them but is also sustainable for you in the long term, which is you no longer being responsible for every single failure or success in your classroom. All right, teacher friends. That wraps up today’s episode. If you’re looking for an easy way to start simplifying your life as a secondary science teacher had to It’s not rocket science classroom.com/challenge to grab your classroom reset challenge. And guess what? It’s totally free. Thanks so much for tuning in, and I’ll see you here next week. Until then, I’ll be rooting for you teacher friend.